S1187-118

Introduced

To establish the right to counsel, at Government expense for those who cannot afford counsel, for people facing removal.

118th Congress Introduced Apr 18, 2023

Analysis under review: This bill has generated analysis that may be too generic or incomplete. Clause-level evidence remains available below.

Summary

What This Bill Does

This bill creates a right to free legal representation for anyone facing deportation or immigration proceedings who cannot afford an attorney. It establishes a new federal organization called the Office of Immigration Representation to provide public defenders for immigration courts, similar to how public defenders exist for criminal cases.

Who Benefits and How

Immigrants facing deportation proceedings who cannot afford lawyers will receive free legal representation. Immigration attorneys and legal service providers will see significant new employment opportunities and funding. Legal aid organizations specializing in immigration will receive federal contracts and support.

Who Bears the Burden and How

Federal taxpayers will fund the new Office of Immigration Representation through open-ended appropriations. The Department of Homeland Security and immigration courts may face longer case processing times due to increased legal challenges. Federal budget will be impacted as funding must match a ratio tied to immigration enforcement spending.

Key Provisions

  • Guarantees appointed counsel for all individuals in removal, exclusion, deportation, and bond proceedings
  • Creates the Office of Immigration Representation as an independent nonprofit corporation
  • Establishes regional public defender organizations and panel attorney systems
  • Requires minimum funding tied to federal immigration enforcement spending

Evidence Chain:

This summary is generated from the full bill text using AI analysis. Expand "Detailed Analysis" below for identified beneficiaries/burden bearers.

At a Glance

What This Bill Does

Establishes a constitutional right to government-appointed counsel for individuals in immigration proceedings who cannot afford representation, creating a comprehensive public defender system for immigration courts.

Key Policy Areas

Immigration, Legal Services, Civil Rights, Federal Appropriations

Primary Purpose

Establishes a constitutional right to government-appointed counsel for individuals in immigration proceedings who cannot afford representation, creating a comprehensive public defender system for immigration courts.

Policy Domains

Immigration Legal Services Civil Rights Federal Appropriations

Title I - Right to Counsel

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Immigrants facing deportation
  • Immigration attorneys
  • Legal aid organizations
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: is

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
  • Immigration courts
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: is

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title II - Office of Immigration Representation

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Immigration attorneys
  • Legal service providers
  • Community defender organizations
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: is

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal budget
  • Office of Management and Budget
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: is

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title III - Authorization of Appropriations

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Office of Immigration Representation
  • Immigration public defenders
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: is

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
  • Federal budget
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: is

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Legislative Progress

Introduced
Introduced Committee Passed
Apr 18, 2023

Mrs. Gillibrand (for herself, Mr. Booker, Mr. Padilla, Mr. Markey, …

Stakeholder Effects

cui bono?

How this legislation distributes effects. Mention counts reflect frequency, not effect magnitude.

Professional Services
11 mentions across 9 clauses
+11 positive

Community Defender Organizations, Experienced immigration attorneys, Expert witnesses and investigators

N/A
8 mentions across 7 clauses
+4 positive -4 negative

Immigrants in deportation or removal proceedings, Immigrants in detention, Immigrants seeking asylum or humanitarian relief

Positive-direction: Immigrants in deportation or removal proceedings, Immigrants in detention, Immigrants seeking asylum or humanitarian relief, Immigrants who cannot afford legal representation

Negative-direction: Taxpayers

Government
4 mentions across 4 clauses
+2 positive -2 negative

Federal employee benefit programs, Immigration courts, Office of Immigration Representation

Positive-direction: Office of Immigration Representation

Negative-direction: Federal employee benefit programs, Immigration courts

Educational Services
1 mention across 1 clause
+1 positive

Immigration attorney training providers

Healthcare
1 mention across 1 clause
+1 positive

Mental health service providers

Social Services
1 mention across 1 clause
+1 positive

Social service organizations

Civic & Social Organizations
1 mention across 1 clause
+1 positive

Community-based immigration organizations

14/16
sections analyzed
Full impact breakdown

Bill Structure & Actor Mappings

Who is "The Secretary" in each section?

Domains
Immigration Civil Rights
Domains
Legal Services Immigration
Actor Mappings
"the_board"
→ Board of Directors of the Office of Immigration Representation
"the_office"
→ Office of Immigration Representation
"local_board"
→ Local Immigration Representation Board
"the_director"
→ Director of the Office of Immigration Representation
Domains
Federal Appropriations
Actor Mappings
"omb"
→ Office of Management and Budget

Key Definitions

Terms defined in this bill

5 terms
"Board" §201

The Board of Directors of the Office of Immigration Representation

"Immigration Public Defender Organization" §201_ipdo

An organization established by a Local Board to provide immigration representation

"Office" §201_office

The Office of Immigration Representation established under section 202

"Director" §201_director

The Director of the Office of Immigration Representation appointed pursuant to section 206(k)(1)

"Local Board" §201_local_board

A local immigration representation board established within a region

We use a combination of our own taxonomy and classification in addition to large language models to assess meaning and potential beneficiaries. High confidence means strong textual evidence. Always verify with the original bill text.

Learn more about our methodology