HR5457-118

Introduced

To support carbon dioxide removal research and development, and for other purposes.

118th Congress Introduced Sep 14, 2023

Analysis under review: This bill has generated analysis that may be too generic or incomplete. Clause-level evidence remains available below.

Summary

What This Bill Does

This bill creates a coordinated federal research program to develop technologies that remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. It directs multiple federal agencies - including the Department of Energy, Department of Agriculture, EPA, NSF, NASA, Interior, Commerce, and Defense - to conduct research on methods like direct air capture, soil carbon sequestration, forest management, ocean-based removal, and mineralization.

Who Benefits and How

Research institutions and universities (especially land-grant colleges) benefit from new grant programs and authorized appropriations totaling hundreds of millions of dollars over 10 years. Clean technology companies developing carbon capture equipment, sorbents, and materials receive federal R&D support. Agricultural interests benefit from research into soil carbon practices and biomass conversion.

Who Bears the Burden and How

Taxpayers fund the authorized appropriations across all agencies. Federal agencies face new coordination mandates and reporting requirements. No significant regulatory burdens are imposed on private industry - this is primarily a research authorization bill.

Key Provisions

  • Establishes Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management at DOE to coordinate all federal carbon removal R&D
  • Authorizes $10M/year for USDA agricultural carbon removal research (2024-2033)
  • Directs NSF to fund research on materials, biological processes, and social impacts
  • Requires NASA to conduct satellite monitoring of forest carbon stocks
  • Mandates lifecycle environmental and environmental justice analyses of all removal technologies

Evidence Chain:

This summary is generated from the full bill text using AI analysis. Expand "Detailed Analysis" below for identified beneficiaries/burden bearers.

At a Glance

What This Bill Does

Establishes a comprehensive federal research, development, and demonstration program for carbon dioxide removal technologies across multiple agencies including DOE, USDA, EPA, NSF, NASA, Interior, Commerce, and DOD.

Key Policy Areas

Energy, Environment, Agriculture, Research & Development, Climate Change

Primary Purpose

Establishes a comprehensive federal research, development, and demonstration program for carbon dioxide removal technologies across multiple agencies including DOE, USDA, EPA, NSF, NASA, Interior, Commerce, and DOD.

Policy Domains

Energy Environment Agriculture Research & Development Climate Change

Title I - Department of Energy

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Clean technology companies
  • National laboratories
  • Direct air capture technology developers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
  • DOE staff
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title V - Department of Interior

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Mining companies
  • Carbon storage project developers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title X - International Collaboration

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • International research collaborators
  • US climate diplomacy
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • OSTP staff
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title II - Department of Agriculture

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Agricultural researchers
  • Land-grant universities
  • Farmers adopting carbon practices
  • Forestry sector
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title IV - Department of Defense

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Coastal restoration contractors
  • Coastal communities
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title IX - National Science Foundation

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • University researchers
  • Materials scientists
  • Social scientists studying climate policy
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title VI - Department of Transportation

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Green cement and concrete manufacturers
  • Construction materials innovators
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title III - Department of Commerce

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Ocean research institutions
  • Construction materials industry
  • Carbon measurement technology providers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title VII - Environmental Protection Agency

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Environmental research community
  • Communities near carbon removal sites
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
  • EPA staff
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Title VIII - NASA

Identified Gains
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Climate scientists
  • Forest carbon monitoring researchers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Identified Costs
Contextual inference, no direct clause citation
  • Federal taxpayers
Model: N/A | Version: bill_summary_v2 | Source: ih

Contextual inference, no direct clause citation

Legislative Progress

Introduced
Introduced Committee Passed
Sep 14, 2023

Mr. Tonko (for himself, Ms. Clark of Massachusetts, Mr. Peters, …

Stakeholder Effects

cui bono?

How this legislation distributes effects. Mention counts reflect frequency, not effect magnitude.

Research & Science
19 mentions across 17 clauses
+19 positive

Agricultural research institutions, Agricultural researchers, Bioenergy researchers

Government
15 mentions across 15 clauses
+6 positive -9 negative

Agricultural Research Service, Army Corps of Engineers, Bureau of Land Management

Positive-direction: Agricultural Research Service, Army Corps of Engineers, EPA Office of Research and Development, Forest Service, NASA Earth Science Division, USGS

Negative-direction: Bureau of Land Management, Department of Agriculture, Department of Energy, NIST, NOAA, Natural Resources Conservation Service, Office of Science and Technology Policy

Technology
13 mentions across 12 clauses
+12 positive ?1 uncertain

Carbon capture equipment manufacturers, Carbon capture technology companies, Carbon capture technology developers

Construction
4 mentions across 3 clauses
+4 positive

Carbon-sequestering materials manufacturers, Coastal restoration contractors, Green cement and concrete manufacturers

General Public
4 mentions across 3 clauses
+4 positive

Coastal communities, Communities near abandoned mines, Communities near potential carbon removal sites

Agriculture
3 mentions across 3 clauses
+3 positive

Biochar producers, Farmers participating in conservation programs, Seed and crop genetics companies

Education
3 mentions across 2 clauses
+1 positive ?2 uncertain

1994 tribal institutions, Land-grant universities

Renewable Energy
2 mentions across 2 clauses
+2 positive

Algae biofuel companies, Biomass processing companies

27/29
sections analyzed
Full impact breakdown

Bill Structure & Actor Mappings

Who is "The Secretary" in each section?

Domains
Energy Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_director"
→ Director of Office of Science
"the_secretary"
→ Secretary of Energy
"the_assistant_secretary"
→ Assistant Secretary for Fossil Energy and Carbon Management
Domains
Agriculture Environment
Actor Mappings
"the_secretary"
→ Secretary of Agriculture
"the_under_secretary"
→ Under Secretary for Research, Education, and Economics
Domains
Environment Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_director"
→ Director of NIST
"the_secretary"
→ Secretary of Commerce
"the_under_secretary"
→ Under Secretary of Commerce for Oceans and Atmosphere
Domains
Environment Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_secretary"
→ Secretary of Defense
"chief_of_engineers"
→ Chief of Engineers (Army Corps)
Domains
Public Lands Environment
Actor Mappings
"the_director"
→ Director of USGS
"the_secretary"
→ Secretary of the Interior
"assistant_secretary"
→ Assistant Secretary of Land and Minerals Management
Domains
Transportation Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_secretary"
→ Secretary of Transportation
Domains
Environment Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_administrator"
→ Administrator of EPA
"assistant_administrator"
→ Assistant Administrator of Research and Development
Domains
Science Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_administrator"
→ Administrator of NASA
Domains
Science Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_director"
→ Director of NSF
Domains
International Affairs Research & Development
Actor Mappings
"the_director"
→ Director of OSTP

Note: The Secretary refers to different Cabinet secretaries depending on the title: Energy (Title I), Agriculture (Title II), Commerce (Title III), Defense (Title IV), Interior (Title V), Transportation (Title VI)

Key Definitions

Terms defined in this bill

4 terms
"Department" §201a

The Department of Agriculture

"Secretary" §201b

The Secretary of Agriculture (in Title II)

"land-grant colleges and universities" §201c

As defined in section 1404 of the National Agricultural Research, Extension, and Teaching Policy Act of 1977, including 1994 Institutions

"carbon-sequestering new material" §601a

A novel formulation of cement, concrete, or aggregate that allows captured carbon dioxide to be sequestered

We use a combination of our own taxonomy and classification in addition to large language models to assess meaning and potential beneficiaries. High confidence means strong textual evidence. Always verify with the original bill text.

Learn more about our methodology